Simple & Easy No Bake Frozen Cherry Custard Pie Recipe

No Bake Frozen Cherry Custard Pie Recipe

No Bake Frozen Cherry Custard PieNo Bake Frozen Cherry Custard Pie Recipe

No Bake Frozen Cherry Custard Pie Recipe

Independence Day is quickly approaching and if you want to celebrate July 4th in style, take a look at this absolutely delicious cherry pie that we came up with. Not only does it have fresh cherries, it also has frozen vanilla custard or you can make it with ice cream which is….OMG…amazing! This no bake frozen cherry custard pie recipe is super easy, and the results are awesome! It is a dish that is easily made ahead, making it perfect for entertaining or cook out night.
No Bake Frozen Cherry Custard Pie Recipe 2 No Bake Frozen Cherry Custard Pie Recipe 3

No Bake Frozen Cherry Custard Pie Recipe


  • 1 tub vanilla frozen custard
  • 3/4 cup of chopped fresh cherries, pitted
  • 1 graham cracker pie crust
  • 1/4 cup of cream
  • 4 oz chocolate

No Bake Frozen Cherry Custard Pie Recipe 4No Bake Frozen Cherry Custard Pie Recipe 6 No Bake Frozen Cherry Custard Pie Recipe 7No Bake Frozen Cherry Custard Pie Recipe 8No Bake Frozen Cherry Custard Pie Recipe 9No Bake Frozen Cherry Custard Pie Recipe 10No Bake Frozen Cherry Custard Pie Recipe 11No Bake Frozen Cherry Custard Pie Recipe 13 No Bake Frozen Cherry Custard Pie Recipe 14Directions

  1. Allow the custard to soften slightly on the counter.  Place in a large bowl with the cherries.  Fold together.  Pour the custard into the pie crust and freeze.
  2. Warm the cream in the microwave. It is hot enough when it starts to bubble.  Pour in the chocolate and allow it to rest for one minute.  Wisk together to form a ganache.
  3. Pour the ganache over the frozen pie.  Place pie in the freezer for several hours.
  4. Serve with whipped cream.

There is just something so inherently delicious about an ice cream pie and it's even better when it's made with frozen custard. There is just something about having crust, toppings and ice cream or frozen custard all melded together in one perfect dish. This ice cream pie is so easy that you will want to make it again and again. You can make them as edible gifts or just to have a few extra in your freezer. We hope that you are inspired by this No Bake Frozen Cherry Custard Pie Recipe. Happy creating!

No Bake Frozen Cherry Custard PieNo Bake Frozen Cherry Custard PieNo Bake Frozen Cherry Custard Pie Recipe 17

« Previous PostKitchenAid Artisan Mini Mixer Review available at Best Buy

Next Post »Graphic Pillows: A Bold Addition to Your Decor

You May Also Like

92 Comments Leave a Comment »

  1. Robin (Masshole Mommy)

    That looks awesome! I love pie for dessert and this one sounds like a real winner.

  2. This looks awesome. I bought a bag of cheeries yesterday but now it’s almost gone, I love snacking on them. This frozen pie looks crazy good.

  3. Becca Z

    These flavors are fantastic! I would def go for an assemble yourself parfait bar with several flavors of custard and lots of choices for the parfait layers….brownie chunks, pound cake cubes, broken cookies, whipped cream, raspberries, chocolate chips, chopped nuts, granola, diced peanut butter cups, banana slices, etc.

  4. Kristen

    The strawberries are so amazing this year…I’d serve up some vanilla custard with fresh berries.

  5. I had no idea that Dreyers/EDYS made a custard and those pictures made my mouth water! All I came up with was a piece of bread and almond butter. The recipe looks fairly uncomplicated so I might even make it fairly soon!

  6. rose

    I don’t have any ideas, except trying to make it watermelon flavored.

  7. I entered your giveaway! Pretty cool recipe too. Will try it if I win! 😛

  8. laura ari

    I’d use the custard to make an ice cream cake for fourth of july.

  9. Ohh my gosh! How do you make such delicious recipes? I totally need to be your neighbor.

  10. I’ve been munching on fresh cherries all summer long. It’s one of my favorite fruits. You’ve taken them to a whole new level and now I’m craving a piece of your frozen cherry custard pie. What a perfect summertime dessert! Looks so yummy!

  11. Kristin K

    Even though you’ve provided a detailed recipe, I am all thumbs in the kitchen, and don’t know if I would be able to attempt this. Although, I am not adverse to eating it, if it was offered to me!! LOL

  12. christopher sorel

    whoopie cake with custard in between is what we do

  13. Samantha C.

    Anything mixed with brownies always makes for a great sundae treat!

  14. wow that looks INTENSE and super filling.

    I don’t know how many bites I could take before feeling guilty for my diet ! looks delicious though!


  15. Barrie

    I’d top the vanilla custard with blueberries and strawberries to make a healthy, tasty and festive celebration treat!

  16. Alina

    love this recipe! I live in Michigan and we’re known for our cherries! I’d also try it with raspberries. YUM!

  17. Oh my goodness! It looks like I will be making this for our next picnic, it looks so good!

  18. Sean

    Drooling over here over this recipe. I would use blueberries and a hint of mint.

  19. I don’t think I’ve ever had a custard pie. That looks so good. I’m glad that it’s so easy to make too. I’ll make one soon!

  20. Leigh Anne Borders

    That looks delicious and easy to make. I did not know that they had custard available.

  21. @momwgravesdzz

    This recipe looks soo good!! Thanks for sharing!

  22. Heather Poindexter

    This pie looks crazy good! I would add some blueberries as well as the cherries to make it more patriotic.

  23. Amanda Whitley

    i would top mine with whipped cream blueberries and strawberries for some red white and blue fun!

  24. I only like plain ice cream and I don’t like chunks of food and such in my food. With that being say THIS LOOKS GOOD!

  25. livivua

    add cream cheesecake rasperries and blueberries

  26. Oh my goodness, this cherry and frozen custard pie looks SO good! I love anything with cherries in it, so I’m sure I’ll love this!

  27. Karen D

    I would love to make a sundae buffet with homemade sauces (fruit and fudge) whipped cream and chopped nuts, and have some fun.

  28. That pie looks so good! I would use the vanilla custard and make chocolate chip cookies and put the custard in the middle like ice cream cookies.

  29. This just might have been the most beautiful dessert I’ve seen in months! I absolutely love fresh cherries and frozen custard is a favorite of mine, too. Must. Have.

  30. That looks really amazing and I love that it’s an ice cream pie! This would be perfect for so many summer gatherings and I can’t wait to try making it myself!

  31. Rebecca Swenor

    This Fresh Cherry Frozen Custard Pie sounds and looks totally delicious. I have not yet tried Edy’s Frozen Custard yet so I will have to get some and make this pie for sure. I love that it has the fresh cherries in it . Yummy!!! Thanks for sharing.

  32. ewhatley

    Make a patriotic red, white and blue dessert using vanilla custard topped with blueberries and strawberries (or cherries).

  33. Linda Manns Linneman

    This pie looks wonderful. Wish I had some right now. Thank you so much for sharng

  34. Starla B

    Oh my goodness- you are killing me with all of these yummy recipes! I would love to make a frozen custard popsicle and add different toppings some as fresh berries or even mint chocolate chip!

  35. Oh my, does that ever look yummy! I love Edy’s and I can’t wait to start making delicious recipes with their ice cream!

  36. That looks awesome. We are having friends over tomorrow. May have to ask my hubby to make this for us. Looks yummy

  37. I just got some new popsicle molds so I would put some frozen custard in them, freeze, then release to dip in some chocolate! YUM!

  38. This looks so good. I haven’t tried custard yet. This would be perfect for a 4th of July dessert.

  39. Jeana B.

    You can do wonders with EDY’s. I’ll surely be getting back to this recipe from time to time.

  40. Carolsue

    I would definitely try the recipe for Frozen Custard Hot Fudge & Strawberry Sundae!

  41. OMG, this frozen pie is calling my name! I can’t say no to this, so I’m definitely making this.

  42. Ohhh nooo, this looks soooo good! Mind sharing some? I am definitely trying this this weekend.

  43. oh wow, yum yum yum!! I need me a piece of this pie please

  44. Rosey

    Now that’s the kind of dessert I could get into. What a great way to use the cherry too, which is one of my most favorite flavors.

  45. Wow. This looks really great. I’ve never seen a pie look so good! Yum. My whole family would love this.

  46. Krystal

    It looks like a refreshing treat for a hot summer day! I need to make more of my own pies!

  47. Wow! This looks absolutely amazing! I bet my husband would be one happy man if I made this for him!

  48. I must make this this weekend. It looks amazing and has me drooling right now. I love cherries.

  49. Ashley Perez

    This looks amazing 🙂

  50. Wow. That looks so yummy!! Great summer dessert to enjoy on a hot day.

  51. That looks like such a delicious and refreshing dessert for summer! It’s perfect for 4th of July parties!

  52. Ann Bacciaglia

    This looks so delicious. I will have to try making this on the weekend for my BBQ. I am sure it will be a huge hit.

  53. As crazy as this is, I haven’t tried anything with cherries and chocolate together. I wonder if we’ll like it!

  54. I’ve only had frozen custard once before (on a road trip through Oklahoma). I loved it. I wish we had it up here in New England. I’m glad that I can go find it in the grocery store now!

  55. Sandy KS

    This cherry custard pie look delicious and easy to make. reading through the recipe. I was sure it was take longer to create. Wow, was I stunned how it easy it was to make.

  56. Maria C

    triple chocolate cheese cake for me

  57. Tina W

    Sadly, we will be staying in this weekend since my Dad is not feeling up to parties or outings.
    BUT: cherry vanilla ice cream is his daily treat, so this pie is right up his alley! He’s actually a little mad at me for showing him the pictures since I can’t make it tonight, gotta wait for someone to hang out with him so I can run to the store for the pie crust)

  58. That looks so yummy right now! I could use that dessert!

  59. This looks amazing. Using the chocolate as a top crust is a great idea.

  60. dhess

    looks so going to try it this weekend.thanks for sharing this awesome recipe

  61. This look amazing!! I love anything cherry but this may be the best thing I have seen in a while!! I need to try it ASAP!!

  62. Kristin K

    This looks like a scrumptious dessert! Full of good things like cherries, custard and chocolate!!! Everything one wants in a dessert!!!

  63. This looks incredibly amazing! What a simple way to make a fancy dessert!

  64. This would be a much loved treat around here. One kid LOVES cherries like you would not believe. I will have to give it a whirl and see how it comes out here!

  65. I’m not a huge fan of pies or cherries, but THAT looks amazing! I would totally try that!

  66. Ashley Perez

    looks delish 🙂

  67. Oh wow! That looks like the perfect dessert for me!

  68. I’ve never seen or heard of anything like this before. Sounds like a great recipe! Thanks for sharing.

  69. Wow, that looks really good. Nice pie, came out looking great, so I am sure it tastes great!

  70. Christina Rodriguez

    This looks soooo amazing. I can not wait to make this. My husband is going to love !

  71. Gotham13

    Yes! Thank you everyone for everything.

  72. Wow a custard pie! I would of never thought ice cream could be used into making a pie like this!

  73. chickie brewer

    It looks so good and delcious… I would used custard in some recipe but not sure what.

  74. Joe Bond

    Wow this is awesome love cherries and custard

  75. Pavel Arturo Betancourt

    I’d love to try it, it looks delicious

  76. Linda Manns Linneman

    This pie sounds so good. It sounds like a great refreshing dessert for this hot and humid summer. Thank you so much for sharing

  77. Kristin K

    This Fresh Cherry & Frozen Custard Pie sounds absolutely delish!!! It would be great for any holiday or special event! I love the design and the ingredients!!! Thanks for sharing the recipe!!!

  78. What a delightful summer treat! I appreciate you sharing this awesome post with Full Plate Thursday and have a great day.
    Come Back Soon!
    Miz Helen

  79. This pie looks so delightful and inviting! Pinning for later, visiting from Treasure Box Tuesday! 🙂 Thanks for sharing.

  80. My pie making skills aren’t the best, but I am trying to improve. This looks so awesome though.

  81. Thanks for linking up at Best of the Weekend!

  82. Oh my! This looks so fabulous! Pinned and tweeted. Please join us tonight at 7 pm, and party with us. I can’t wait to see your new masterpieces or amazing classics! Lou Lou Girls

  83. lindsey

    Oh my goodness that looks delicious!

  84. john hutchens

    this looks delicious. I like that it seems simple to make. I am sure my family would love it. Thanks for the recipe

  85. Julie Wood

    What an awesome recipe! I love Eddy’s Frozen Custard and think it will make a delicious pie! This pie looks easy to make, and I have some cherries and I will be making this recipe!

  86. Pamela Gurganus

    I can’t get over how unbelievably easy this recipe is! My mom would absolutely love this…cherry and chocolate are her favorite flavors, especially when paired together. I can’t wait to make this for her. Thank you for sharing!

  87. This is right up my alley! It combines all of my favorite things – cherries, chocolate and no baking!

  88. Pingback: Delicious Summer Pie Recipes - Food Fun & Faraway Places

  89. Pingback: 15 Pie Recipes Dessert Pumpkin Apple Chocolate Silk Pecan

  90. Pingback: Copycat DIY Disney Frozen Pineapple Dole Whip Divine Lifestyle

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *